The 1100th Movement

Let's all head to the tipping point axle and hang ten.

Friday, March 30, 2007

Fun with Syllogisms

If reason is the source of law,
then reason predates law;
if natural laws exist, then
reason must predate nature;
if reason predates nature
a reasoning awareness created natural law.

However, if time and space have always existed
natural law has always existed, and if
natural law has always existed no reason
was involved in its existence;
therefor if no reason predates natural law
no reason can be found in natural law.

But if humans are creatures of natural law,
and human law is created by human reason, then
human reason can only exist if
a reasoning awareness created natural law.

Thursday, March 29, 2007

On the Possibilities of Paradox

"A statement, view or doctrine contrary to received opinion; an assertion seemingly absurd but really correct..." Concise English Dictionary

I have a theory that the human capacity to endure paradox, to still be able to think while within the midst of absurd contradictions is one of the things that makes us human. And may be linked to our destiny as a species. Strict rationalists who think otherwise will assert that one of the contradictions is false, and that paradox is a screen for muddy thinking, but I don't think it's that easy to dismiss. I go back to the benobos and chimps of an an earlier post. At one point in the evolutionary chain we all had a common ancestor, the chimps went one way, the benobos went another, and we went up the middle. The chimps maintain their borders by killing chimps from other family groups, the benobos maintain their borders by having sexual relations with their neighbour. The common ancestor found the issue of border so fractious it slit in three. The human capacity to make love or war appears to have given us an edge over the chimps or the bedobos.
The existence of the Roman Alphabet is a case in point. It's actually the Latin alphabet. The Romans and the Latin's were at one point two distinct tribes.
They Romans conquered the Latins, and in the way of such things, the Latin men were killed, while the Latin women were kept alive. The mother tongue of new born Romans however became Latin. As Lewis Thomas points out in Lives of the Cell, symbiosis began as failed attempts at predation.
In other tribal instances, negotiated peace became the norm, and conflicts were avoided through marriage, and dynastic alliances, and mother tongues preserved the remains of lost cultures.
The contradictions of war or peace couldn't be abolished, they had to be negotiated in subtler ways than was allowed either the benobo's or the chimp's methodologies.
I'll come back to this idea of paradox and human destiny.

Sunday, March 25, 2007

The Randomness of Rand

I spent some time at New Critics in a long thread with some of Ayn Rand's supporters (not indigenous to New Critics). I came to the conclusion that there is a cult-like quality to her followers, in which she is a prophetess and they her adherents.
In a lot of ways it was a very enjoyable discussion, until it became obvious that they accept no argument that isn't already part of their creed. They use their version of the language of Objectivism, and the definitions that go with that language to create circular arguments, the discussion never really goes anywhere because their sole purpose is proselytizing the Randian POV as if it were theological truth, rather than just post-theological rationalism.
They believe Capitalism is good, collectivism is evil, and that man's right to do as he pleases with the environment is good, while environmental romanticism is evil; selfishness is good, altruism is evil.
I certainly don't profess to know much about Rand, and nor am I particular interested anymore. I was when the thread began but then I ran into her camp followers and realized I have better things to do.
The whole question of objectivism/rationalism intrigues me. I tend to be rather invidualistic in the way I have constructed my thought, for instance, from the theologian Francis Schaeffer I used his explanation of pre-suppositional philosophy to help me understand a statement by the Canadian rebel of the 1830's, William Lyon MacKenzie - who noted that 'a mind of character was created by the sequence of its ideas.' Schaeffer believed that there were three pre-suppositions about the nature of existence, and that depending on which of the three you chose, the rest of your ideas about life would flow from there.
The three presuppositions are that life was created, life is random and life is an illusion. By Schaeffer's estimations only a created universe could account for everything from rational thought to imaginative art. A random universe would only yield randomness and could only be said to produce a rational universe when a proponent left their presupposition behind them as soon as they chose it. That abandonment of the random choice immediately after its articulation enabled them to hop the tracks as it were and so ride the train that was pulling out on the tracks that followed the sequences of ideas of a presupposed created universe. Similarly no one can actually live in a world in which they think everything is random so too no one can live in a world in which everything is thought to be Illusory.

Faith to Schaeffer was rational precisely because presuppositional philosophy and the choice of believing in a created world was the only choice which explained why choice had meaning. The existence of meaning cannot be explained by randomness, not even the word random can be explained by randomness. It's like believing in 'spontaneous generation' on a cosmic scale. It's surprising how many scientists seem to believe in cosmic spontanenous generation.

I realize that notions of a created universe give some people the creeps, but as far as I'm concerned, as a presupposition it's still the only one that accounts for meaning. 'Creationists' like Objectivists come in many flavours. Those who choose randomness because they despise one flavour of creationism still have to
hop onto the creation bandwagon because the sequence of ideas that flow from a world governed by meaningful laws will not flow from spontaneous generation
Ayn Rand's philosophy is post-theological, and while she doesn't believe Man created the universe, for her, every individual is a god, and his reason is everything. Man's emotional intuition is not only meaningless to Randians, but appears to be regarded as conceptually evil. Rationalism is the source of understanding to them because intuition in their thought appears to be anti-rationale. Creative objectivism finds understanding in the emotional as well as the intellectual, because everything has meaning, and not just the rational. If it exists, it has meaning. And there is plenty of evidence for the existence of intuition, Ayn Rand's views notwithstanding.

Having said all that, the sequence of ideas that follow the presupposition of creation do not lead directly to 'Creationism' or anything else, each idea is chosen (in each case by an individual, whether by acquiescence to stronger willed people, or by conscious decision)thus what I mean by a created universe, while similar in some ways to what Schaeffer meant by it is distinctly personal.

Because Randians take the notion of evil from Theology to describe things they don't like, but place man at the centre of the universe, it is quite evident that their views of evil flow from Rand herself, or least from Rand's conception of Objectivism, which makes Randians practitioners of a form of Creative Objectivism, but with Rand has the creator of their sequential thought.

Evil, as a theological understanding is discerned by the spirit, not conceived through rationalizations. If fact, one could argue that rationalization is a demonic parody of discernment.

For Randians, common good is evil not because it can be discerned to be so by the spirit but because in the self-centric random-creative objectivism of Ms. Rand, she rationalizes it to be so because it gets in the way of self-fullment, and we should take her word for it, like her followers have. It remains however a random deduction made by a human god and in fact denies my rights has an individual to believe that self-sacrifice is sometimes the only thing that makes rational sense or intuited far-sightedness.
Granted, certain forms of self-sacrifice are not genuinely self-sacrificial at all, but rather a twisted form of 'other'-sacrifice into which people in authority brow beat or bully the impressionable, much like soldiers who believe political lies and lay down their lives for those lies, or like workers who die in unsafe working conditions because bosses demand they do things they shouldn't.
To the degree that Ms. Rand promotes a certain form of heroic selfishness I can appreciate what she means, to the degree that she condemns self-sacrifice itself as evil, I think she's an idiot.

The sequence of her ideas that led her to her random pronouncements can be traced back to the place she jumped off her random presupposition and onto the train that began with a created universe. She borrowed the idea of objective reality and then preceded to make random declarations of what was good and what was evil, and called it new Romanticism.

From my perspective, in a created universe I can look at the word Rand and random and find a metaphorical dynamism that produces both rational and intuitive sense: something wicked this way comes, and it is masked as a source of light.

Monday, March 19, 2007

Communitarian vs Independence

As I make my way around the sundry web logs that pop up while searching the word communitarian I am constantly struck by the rancour the word seems to arouse in some sectors. I suppose to the extent that I believe that most people are in fact independent communitarians who want to preserve some measure of their independence while working towards the common good I knew that separating the terms created two solitudes, and that like all solitudes, they breed distrust and distaste of the other.

I suppose it's no accident that most of the rancour that I find comes from American blogs that keep the terms firmly divided into irreconcilable political camps. I go back to my belief that Americans hate one another so viscerally that they can barely contain their contempt for each other. It's nation so deeply divided that I can't imagine anyone ever uniting it.

As I've said in other posts, Canada was created by Sir John A MacDonald using a coalition party he called the Liberal Conservatives. Doing so created a pragmatic, non-ideological nation founded more on the reconciliation of Europe's two warring religions, Protestantism and Catholicism, than it did on the uneasy pairings of the two solitudes of French and English. That rooting in religious reconciliation is at the root of our efforts to reconcile the world's religions within our borders in the past few decades.

For those who saw Pierre Trudeau's state funeral in that magnificent cathedral in Montreal, the television commentators went to some lengths to define the former Prime Minister's faith as Catholic Personalism. Which is essentially a form of high church protestantism. Curiously, his main ally in bringing in the Charter of Rights and Freedoms was Queen Elizabeth, who inherited Henry VIII's pre-excommunication title of Defender of the Faith.

The Charter, which is essentially a charter between a representative of the Eternal Crown (Providence), and the commoners of Canada, bypasses the House of Commons, (which is essentially the will of the governing classes) and creates a new deal between individuals and their community. That deal is rooted in the same power dynamic as MacDonald used with the Liberal Conservatives, and is one I define as Independent Communitarian. We are each of us guaranteed equity in the commonwealth: we are individual before the law, and together, we form a community of customs and traditions that undergo constant renewal.

Afghanistan and the Cause of Service

While I have no problems recognizing that Iraq was an Anglo-American problem created and sustained by Anglo-American interests and therefore not in Canada's best interests to enter their stinking little world of secrets and lies, Afghanistan poses a slightly different problem for me.
I have no problem realizing that the Taliban arose because of the hypocrisy of Anglo-American interests in Afghanistan (and throughout the Arab world), but unlike Saddam Hussein who was essentially an American puppet who cut his own strings and found a demon willing to keep him dancing for a while, the Taliban is 'other'. They're religious hypocrites in the same way that the Bush League are, but that's not the real point of this post.
It is the question of Canadian soldiers being in Afghanistan and the notion of supporting our troops in the field that concerns me. This is one of the issues where Stephen Harper really doesn't speak for me. I'm being told that I must support a policy in which I am being asked (by extension of my being a Canadian citizen) to support the murder of individuals, and to support Canadian soldiers willing to die in my name (again on behalf of me being Canadian.)
People who want to kill on behalf of Canadian policy and people who want to die on behalf of Canadian policy need people like me who want to know what the real policy here is. I can sense for myself that there is something evil about the Taliban that needs to be opposed with force if necessary, not because force will necessarily make the situation better, but because the Taliban needs to be stopped, so that the possibility of betterment might exist.
But because I recognize that someone like Stephen Harper is only in power because he, like George Bush, has the support of oil industry interests which I do no share, I want the policy on Afghanistan to be rooted in something other than one hundred year old profiteering policies that created the mess there in the first place.

Granted, Harper didn't put us into Afghanistan, the Liberals did, and I trust their interests only slightly more than I trust the Conservatives. But the Liberals didn't make me feel that questioning the policy was an act of betrayal to the soldiers in the field.

There is a genuine policy of hope-making in Afghanistan, but there is also layer upon layer of lies and bullshit rooted in the love of oil money. It is not money itself that is the root of all evil, it is the love of money, and there are too many lovers of oil money making too many fortunes out of the misery of others interwoven throughout this whole issue.

So I can support the troops, but only to the degree that they individually serve a policy of hope-making, and it may be that the good that one individual does has more power than the evil that many others do, so I will continue to offer qualified support. And if our arms dealer Minister of Defense O'Connor wants to accuse me of a lack of patriotism, let him, he's an arms' dealer, what the hell do I care what he thinks about anything ?

Besides, I'm not a patriot, I may be a Canadian nationalist, but a belief in 'my country right or wrong' is demented.

Friday, March 16, 2007

George in Latin America, or the paradox of chimps and benobos

There is something profoundly sad about America's sense of itself as the leader of the 'free world', the defender of democracy etc. when most of it's friends in the world are dictators and bullies. Bush's foray into the hotbeds of democracy oppression is the latest example. I suppose it's the ability of human brains to live with paradox that explains how Americans can disconnect the self-perception of America-the-free with the reality of American-interests, which almost always appear to represent the worst kind of grubby materialist values.
The Christian Right likes to blame the left's immorality for America's troubles, I guess I'm that much more of an extreme protestant that when I look at individualism American-style the most offensive part to me is the worship of Mammon, and the idolatry of capitalism.
I'm more of a free enterprise now ! kind of guy. I believe in the state only to the degree that I believe that when I go into a store I expect there to be service people capable of helping me buy what I need, ie., the government are staff people, they work for the tax credit union that is the citizenry. I'm also a big believer in the notion that one day consumer cooperation will reduce even the most arrogant of corporations to bankruptcy court.
The notion of the human capacity for living with paradox reminds me of the chimpanzee/benobo/human evolutionary split. Allegedly, (therefor metaphorically, parabolicly, and therefor pedagogically useful) the three above mentioned hominids had a common ancestor.
As you may or may not know, one band of chimpanzees controls the borders of their own territory with violence, if they meet a 'foreign chimp' in the liminal regions of their turf a fight ensues: hence the belief that humans derive from a violent ape. The benobos on the other hand, control the borders of their regions with sex. They make love not war.
Humans are capable of either response. Dynastic politics, whether of the national imperialist kind or of the local family compact type, are a way in which the sex or violence option has been used to maintain relative stability among peoples.
The issue being paradox, rather than simply the paradox of sex and violence, and this web log being devoted to the paradox of being both independent and communitarian, then I shouldn't be too surprised that the essential paradox of America is freedom and tyranny.